Article 66 · Antitrust

Will the new Democratic attorneys general in Texas, Iowa and Kansas keep suing BlackRock and State Street over coal?

Three states in a Republican-led antitrust suit against BlackRock and State Street, two of the world's largest asset managers, elected Democratic attorneys general on November 3rd, days after a judge narrowed the damages claims.

Nov 13th, 2026 · 3 min read · By Vektora

What the case is about

BlackRock and State Street are two of the world's largest asset managers. They invest money for others and hold shares in many listed companies, coal producers among them.

Texas and 12 other Republican-led states sued them and a third manager, Vanguard Group, in late 2024. The case is in the federal court for the Eastern District of Texas.

The states say the firms used their stakes in competing coal companies to push them to cut output. Less coal, the states argue, meant higher energy prices for consumers.

The claim rests on the firms' public climate pledges, made through groups such as the Net Zero Asset Managers initiative and Climate Action 100+. Ken Paxton, the outgoing Republican attorney general of Texas, brought the case. He is pictured below.

Woodcut portrait of Ken Paxton

Ken Paxton

Outgoing attorney general of Texas

The Republican who brought the coal case against the asset managers.

What the firms and the courts have said

The firms deny wrongdoing. BlackRock calls the suit "an absurd theory that coal companies conspired with their shareholders to reduce coal production." State Street called it "baseless and without merit."

On August 1st, 2025, Judge Jeremy Kernodle refused to dismiss the case. He wrote that the states lack direct evidence of a conspiracy but plausibly allege one from circumstantial evidence. "This is a close call," he added.

Victor Flatt, an environmental law professor at Case Western Reserve University, told ESG Dive that letting the case go forward does not mean a court will find anti-competitive behavior.

The federal government sided with the states. On May 22nd, 2025, the Federal Trade Commission and the Justice Department filed a statement of interest. It says asset managers can be held liable when they use stock in several competing companies to anticompetitive ends.

Vanguard settled in February 2026 for $29.5 million, Reuters reports. On September 18th, 2026, Bloomberg Law reported that the Justice Department was weighing whether to join the case and had made no final decision.

A smaller case after October 30th

On October 30th, 2026, Kernodle narrowed the damages claims. Law360 reports that the asset managers got the suit pared down.

Claims for electricity buyers survived in two states. Iowa and Nebraska can keep suing on behalf of consumers who pay power bills, because their laws let the attorney general bring such cases, Bloomberg Law reports. Figure 1 sets out the case so far.

Fig. 1

The coal case against the asset managers

  1. Late November 2024Texas and 12 other Republican-led states sue BlackRock, State Street and Vanguard.
  2. May 22nd, 2025The Federal Trade Commission and the Justice Department back the states in a statement of interest.
  3. August 1st, 2025The court refuses to dismiss the case.
  4. February 2026Vanguard settles for $29.5 million.
  5. October 30th, 2026The court narrows the damages claims and keeps claims from Iowa and Nebraska.
  6. November 3rd, 2026Democrats win the attorney general offices in Texas, Iowa and Kansas.

New officials on the plaintiff side

Democrats won attorney general races in Georgia, Iowa, Ohio, Kansas and Texas on November 3rd, Reuters reports. Texas, Iowa and Kansas are plaintiffs in the coal case.

Nathan Johnson, the Democrat elected attorney general of Texas, told Reuters he will assess the pending lawsuits Paxton's office brought. "Everything will be examined," he said.

In Kansas, Democrat Chris Mann beat the Republican attorney general, Kris Kobach. In Iowa, the attorney general-elect is Democrat Nate Willems.

MLex, a legal news service, reports that it is unclear whether the incoming officials will keep pursuing the suit. It adds that the changes could give Florida a larger role in Republican-led challenges to corporate ESG policies. Florida's Republican attorney general, James Uthmeier, won a new term.

What to watch, and by when

Our alert watches for Texas, Iowa or Kansas to file notice in the Eastern District of Texas that it is leaving the case, by February 5th, 2027.

It also watches for a Justice Department filing to join the case by March 31st, 2027. If plaintiff states leave, MLex says, the Justice Department or states such as Florida may carry the case forward.

No source we read reports that any state has withdrawn.

All articlesNext Trump calls new strikes on Iran "highly unlikely" three days after promising a decision soon