Three states suing BlackRock and State Street over coal are getting Democratic attorneys general

A federal judge narrowed the damages claims on October 30th. Days later, Democrats won the attorney general offices in Texas, Iowa and Kansas, all plaintiffs in the case.
Alert analysis
November 8th, 2026
Vektora
Alert typeMarket-Relevant Uncertainty
State withdrawals reportedNone found
CourtEastern District of Texas
Sources9 cited
As ofNov 8th, 2026
Claim goes ahead

Eastern District of Texas

Texas v. BlackRock 1 Aug 2025

Judge Kernodle denied the motion to dismiss and called the circumstantial case for a conspiracy a close call1.

Settled

Eastern District of Texas

Vanguard settlement 26 Feb 2026

Vanguard Group settled the claims against it for $29.5 million and agreed to avoid imposing ESG goals on its investments2.

This case · Claim fails

Eastern District of Texas

Texas v. BlackRock 30 Oct 2026

The court kept indirect purchaser claims from Iowa and Nebraska and narrowed the rest3,4.

Where the courts standAlive but smaller, with new state officials

Source: Bloomberg Law, November 2nd, 20263

Executive Summary

Three of the states suing BlackRock and State Street over coal output have elected Democratic attorneys general. Texas, Iowa and Kansas are plaintiffs3,5, and Reuters reports Democrats will take over their attorney general offices after the November 3rd election5. BlackRock and State Street are two of the world's largest asset managers2. Ken Paxton, the outgoing Republican attorney general of Texas, brought the case5.

The court has also narrowed the damages claims. On October 30th, Judge Jeremy Kernodle of the federal court for the Eastern District of Texas ruled that Iowa and Nebraska can keep pursuing claims on behalf of electricity buyers3. Law360 reports that the other claims were pared down4.

It is not yet clear what the new attorneys general will do. MLex reports it is unclear whether the incoming officials will keep pursuing the suit6. Nathan Johnson, the Democrat elected Texas attorney general, told Reuters he will assess pending lawsuits from Paxton's office before deciding whether to support them5.

Alert type
Market-Relevant Uncertainty
States suing besides Texas
12
Vanguard settlement
$29.5 million
01Risk Matrix

Legal and regulatory risk sit in the middle, and nothing yet forces a remedy on the asset managers.

LegalMediumDamages narrowed, core claims alive

The October 30th ruling left claims from Iowa and Nebraska for electricity buyers3. In August 2025 the same judge described the case for a conspiracy as a close call1.

RegulatoryMediumFederal agencies have sided with the states

The Federal Trade Commission and the Justice Department filed a statement of interest in May 20257. Bloomberg Law reported in September that the Justice Department was weighing a move to join, and that no decision had been made2.

EconomicLowNo remedy or divestment order exists

BlackRock says forced divestment from coal companies would harm their access to capital and could raise energy prices8. No source we read reports a ruling that orders divestment.

ReputationalMediumClimate commitments are the core of the claim

The court noted that the states rely on the firms' public commitments to climate initiatives1.

InvestmentLowOnly one settlement so far

Vanguard paid $29.5 million and agreed to avoid imposing ESG goals on its investments2. BlackRock and State Street deny wrongdoing8.

02Forecast Watch

The first test comes when the new attorneys general take office and decide whether to stay in the case.

Confidence on the mechanism is high: the plaintiffs are state officials, and officials can withdraw or redirect a suit5. Confidence on the horizon is low, because no source says when the new attorneys general will decide6.

Analyst assessment. Each call is scored once its date passes.

35%

At least one of Texas, Iowa or Kansas files notice in the Eastern District of Texas that it is withdrawing from the multistate suit.

Settles Feb 5th, 202789 days left
10%

The Justice Department files to join or intervene in the case, as shown on the court docket.

Settles Mar 31st, 2027143 days left
10%

BlackRock or State Street announces a settlement with the plaintiff states.

Settles Jun 30th, 2027234 days left
  • The court docket in the Eastern District of Texas, updated as filings arrive3.
  • Statements from the Texas, Iowa and Kansas attorney general offices on pending suits5.
  • Any Justice Department filing in the case2.
  • MLex reporting on whether Florida takes a larger role6.
03The Signal

What moved is the plaintiff line-up and the damages claims, not the legal theory.

The legal theory is that the asset managers used their stock holdings and climate commitments to cut coal output and raise prices5. The October 30th ruling and the election changed who is pursuing it and for what damages6.

Threatened, not done: none of the sources we read reports that any state has withdrawn from the case.

04What Happened

The case has run for almost two years, and the last two weeks changed its shape.

Background
Late November 2024
Other.
Texas and 12 other Republican state attorneys general sue BlackRock, State Street and Vanguard2.
May 22nd, 2025
Announcement.
The Federal Trade Commission and the Justice Department file a statement of interest supporting the states7.
August 1st, 2025
Other.
The court denies the motions to dismiss1.
February 2026
Other.
Vanguard settles for $29.5 million2.
October 30th, 2026
Other.
The court narrows the damages claims and keeps claims from Iowa and Nebraska3.
November 3rd, 2026
Other.
Democrats win the attorney general offices in Texas, Iowa and Kansas5.
November 7th, 2026
Other.
Latest. MLex reports the case faces uncertainty6.
05What's Being Overstated

Neither the election nor the ruling ends the case.

  • The claim that the case is over. No source we read reports a withdrawal. Johnson said only that he will assess pending lawsuits5.
  • The claim that the court has found collusion. The August 2025 ruling let the case proceed. A law professor told ESG Dive that this does not mean a court will find anti-competitive behavior9.
  • The claim that Nebraska is out. The October 30th ruling kept Nebraska's claims for electricity buyers3.
06Why It Matters

The case is a test of whether antitrust law reaches the way index fund managers vote and engage with companies.

The suit is one of the most prominent legal challenges to environmental, social and governance (ESG) investing5. The Federal Trade Commission and the Justice Department said asset managers can be held liable when they use stock in competing companies to anticompetitive ends7. BlackRock calls the theory absurd2. If plaintiff states leave, the Justice Department or states such as Florida may carry it forward6.

07Vektora Assessment

The case survives into 2027, smaller and with an uncertain set of plaintiffs.

Confidence: medium. The ruling comes from Bloomberg Law and Law360, the election results from Reuters, and the effect on this case rests on MLex's summary6,3,4,5.

The strongest alternative reading: new attorneys general may keep a suit that is already filed, because a pending case with federal support costs them little7. Against that, Johnson told Reuters he will examine the lawsuits Paxton's office brought5.

What would make this call wrong: a withdrawal notice from Texas, Iowa or Kansas, or a Justice Department filing to join.

08Sources
  1. Texas Judge Greenlights Multi-State Lawsuit Accusing BlackRock, Vanguard, State Street of Using Climate Initiatives to Manipulate Energy Markets. ESG Today, August 4th, 2025
  2. DOJ Weighs Joining Texas BlackRock, State Street Antitrust Case. Bloomberg Law, September 18th, 2026
  3. BlackRock, State Street to Face Purchaser Claims in Collusion Suit. Bloomberg Law, November 2nd, 2026
  4. BlackRock, State Street Get State AG Coal Suit Trimmed. Law360, November 2nd, 2026
  5. Democratic attorney general wins could reshape US lawsuits on abortion, immigration and more. Reuters, November 8th, 2026
  6. Texas-led BlackRock, State Street case clouded by ruling, US state AG changes. MLex, November 7th, 2026
  7. FTC and DOJ File Statement of Interest in Energy Collusion Case Against BlackRock, State Street, and Vanguard. Federal Trade Commission, May 22nd, 2025
  8. BlackRock's response to DOJ and FTC filing. BlackRock, May 22nd, 2025
  9. BlackRock, Vanguard, State Street bid to dismiss coal antitrust case denied. ESG Dive, August 7th, 2025