Report 64 · Labor

A January strike at Volkswagen, then a partial deal, leaves its margin at -1.6% in our tests

Volkswagen ended almost all of its German wage deals and now wants a pay freeze for 2027 and 2028. IG Metall's no-strike clause expires on December 31st.

Run of October 27th, 2026Published November 22nd, 2026Settles February 28th, 2027Run checked 19 of 20 cited claims
The bottom line
In our tests, Volkswagen's margin ends below zero on the path with no new shock. On that path, talks fail and a January strike ends in a partial deal. It also ends below zero under an energy and battery squeeze, and in a long fight over who runs out first. Every other outcome we tested ends above zero.
If nothing changes
If nothing unusual happens, the run follows one of two paths. On the first, talks fail and a January strike ends in a partial deal, with the margin at -1.6%. On the second, a mediator steps in, the margin recovers and it ends at 4.1%.
What it depends on
It depends most on whether the two sides settle before strikes start. The shocks that add most are a dividend-cut deal and a partial deal before a strike runs out of steam.
What to watch
Nov24

Talks on the company wage agreement open in Emden.

Nov30

Our first test: has a joint wage deal been announced?

Dec15

Talks continue in Zwickau.

Dec31

The no-strike clause expires. Warning strikes are allowed from January 1st.

Jan8

Our test: has IG Metall confirmed strikes at the German plants?

Feb28

The question settles.

What is happening
2.8%
Operating margin in 2025, Volkswagen's last full year
Margin in 20252.8
Forecast for 2026, at most1
First nine months of 2026, before one-off charges3.8
Target for 20309
Volkswagen's margin has shrunk since 2022, and wage talks open on November 24th

Volkswagen, the German carmaker, terminated several wage deals with IG Metall, Germany's top industrial union, on September 30th, 2026. They include the umbrella agreement for some 100,000 workers at its main German plants. It sets working hours and holiday pay, among other standards.6

On November 19th, Volkswagen set out its demands. It wants a pay freeze for 2027 and 2028 and an end to two collectively agreed payments. It also wants weekly hours, now 35, to rise or fall with demand. Frank Ischner, of Group Human Resources Management, said the company needs "a quick agreement to counter the high cost pressure".8

IG Metall calls the list a "catalog of horrors" and asks for a 5 percent pay rise. Thorsten Gröger, its chief negotiator, says the conflict "will leave deep scars on the company". The in-house agreement covers about 120,000 employees. Its no-strike clause expires on December 31st, and warning strikes are allowed from January 1st.9

IG Metall's demands come from elected bargaining committees, made up largely of shop stewards from the plants. A smaller committee from the union's district of Lower Saxony and Saxony-Anhalt conducts the talks.9

The talks come as Volkswagen loses money. It reported an operating loss of €5.9 billion for the third quarter, its largest quarterly deficit since late 2015. One-off charges of €8 billion, led by a writedown on its stake in Porsche, drove the loss.2

Volkswagen's operating margin was 2.8% in 2025, Reuters reported in March. Volkswagen then expected 4% to 5.5% for 2026.1

Before one-off charges, Volkswagen's operating return on sales for the first nine months of 2026 was 3.8%.3

In September, Volkswagen cut its forecast for 2026 to an operating return on sales of up to 1 percent. Without the one-off charges, it says the figure would be about 4 percent.4

Volkswagen's Future Plan 2030 targets an operating margin of 9% by 2030. The company says it cannot guarantee work for its plants in Emden, Zwickau, Hanover and Neckarsulm from 2031 to 2034.11

IG Metall points out that Volkswagen paid about 2.6 billion euros in dividends in June. Its largest shareholder, Porsche SE, holds 53.3 percent of the common stock and is controlled by the Porsche and Piëch families. We found no report that ties the dividend to the talks.9

01Where it could landOperating margin, % of sales, at the end of each outcome
A January strike ends with Volkswagen's margin below zero
-10%0%10%Operating lossOperating profitA deal paid for with a dividend cut4.2%A mediator and a margin rebound calm the dispute4.1%A partial deal, then a strike that runs out of steam2.1%Splits inside both camps stall the talks1.6%A scandal and staff poaching upset the talks1.5%Rivals wait while Volkswagen loses money1.3%Lost trust feeds a wave of strikes1.1%Unofficial strikes and a supplier collapse0.6%Strikes spread to plants abroad0.4%A January strike ends in a partial deal-1.6%An energy and battery squeeze-2.1%A long fight over who runs out first-2.3%Today, 2.8%
-10%0%10%Operating lossOperating profitA deal paid for with a dividend cut4.2%A mediator and a margin rebound calm the dispute4.1%A partial deal, then a strike that runs out of steam2.1%Splits inside both camps stall the talks1.6%A scandal and staff poaching upset the talks1.5%Rivals wait while Volkswagen loses money1.3%Lost trust feeds a wave of strikes1.1%Unofficial strikes and a supplier collapse0.6%Strikes spread to plants abroad0.4%A January strike ends in a partial deal-1.6%An energy and battery squeeze-2.1%A long fight over who runs out first-2.3%Dotted mark: today, 2.8%
Each dot is one outcome. The line at zero splits an operating profit from an operating loss.
Part 1The situationWhat is at stake in the Volkswagen wage talks
02Timeline
From the 2024 deal to the talks in Emden
  1. December 2024After two days of warning strikes by about 100,000 workers, IG Metall and Volkswagen agree a deal. Layoffs for operational reasons are ruled out through the end of 2030.10
  2. September 3rdVolkswagen's supervisory board approves its Future Plan 2030, with a further 50,000 job cuts.11
  3. September 30thVolkswagen terminates several wage deals with IG Metall.6
  4. October 23rdIG Metall threatens strikes from January. Volkswagen keeps the termination.5
  5. October 29thVolkswagen reports an operating loss of €5.9 billion for the third quarter.2
  6. November 19thVolkswagen sends IG Metall its demands, including a pay freeze for 2027 and 2028.8
  7. November 24thTalks open in Emden.5
  8. December 15thTalks continue in Zwickau.5
  9. December 31stThe no-strike clause expires.9
Fig. 1Operating margin, % of sales, by year
Volkswagen's operating margin peaked at 7.9% in 2022 and fell to 2.8% in 2025
05102.82016201720182019202020212022202320242025
Reuters' figures from the company accounts.2
03Where
The plants under Volkswagen's in-house wage agreement
Volkswagen plants in Germany named in the dispute
  • Plant under the in-house agreement
  • Plant with no guaranteed work from 2031
GermanyPolandCzechiaNetherlandsFranceBelgium
100 km

Plant locations are shown at the city named. Borders: Natural Earth.

The in-house agreement covers Volkswagen AG plants at Braunschweig, Emden, Hanover, Kassel, Salzgitter and Wolfsburg. Since the start of 2026 it also covers the Saxony sites, Zwickau among them.9

04Who decidesDecisions and conditions
Who decides
DecisionAt the table
Oliver Blume
Chief executive of the Volkswagen Group

His expanded restructuring drive includes plans to cut 100,000 jobs, Reuters reports.7

Thorsten Gröger
IG Metall's chief negotiator at Volkswagen

IG Metall's regional director for Lower Saxony and Saxony-Anhalt. Says "the VW Executive Board is stabbing its employees in the back".9

Daniela Cavallo
Chair of Volkswagen's General Works Council

Says the workforce feels betrayed and that the works council must switch to "confrontational conflict resolution".9

DecisionNegotiating for the company
Kerstin Scholz
Head of Group HR Policy and Governance, Volkswagen

Leads the company's side jointly with Frank Ischner. Arne Meiswinkel, who led before, leaves Volkswagen on December 31st, 2026.8

Frank Ischner
Group Human Resources Management, Volkswagen

Says the company needs a quick agreement and that both sides jointly bear responsibility for its future.8

ConditionWhat nobody at the table decides
One-off charges
Write-downs and restructuring costs

Volkswagen says its 2026 margin would be about 4 percent without them, against up to 1 percent with them.4

The no-strike clause
Part of the in-house agreement

Expires on December 31st. From January 1st, warning strikes are allowed.9

Part 2The outcomesWhere Volkswagen's margin ends in each outcome
05What each shock costsChange in operating margin against the path with no new shock, in percentage points
A deal paid for with a dividend cut adds the most to the margin
−5+5+100The path with no new shockA deal paid for with a dividend cut+6.1A partial deal, then a strike that runs out of steam+4.3A scandal and staff poaching upset the talks+3.3Splits inside both camps stall the talks+3Rivals wait while Volkswagen loses money+2.9Lost trust feeds a wave of strikes+2.7Unofficial strikes and a supplier collapse+2.4Strikes spread to plants abroad+2An energy and battery squeeze+0.9A long fight over who runs out first+0.6
−5+5+100The path with no new shockA deal paid for with a dividend cut+6.1A partial deal, then a strike that runs out of steam+4.3A scandal and staff poaching upset the talks+3.3Splits inside both camps stall the talks+3Rivals wait while Volkswagen loses money+2.9Lost trust feeds a wave of strikes+2.7Unofficial strikes and a supplier collapse+2.4Strikes spread to plants abroad+2An energy and battery squeeze+0.9A long fight over who runs out first+0.6
Each bar is what one shock adds to the margin against the path with no new shock. That path is itself a January strike, so every shock in the run lifts the margin from it.
06If nothing in particular happens
-1.6%A January strike ends in a partial deal
4.1%A mediator and a margin rebound calm the dispute

These are the two paths the run follows when no new shock arrives. One ends with an operating loss, the other with an operating profit.

07The other reading
The case that wages are not what sinks Volkswagen's margin
IG Metall
Says the group's labor cost ratio fell from 17.5 percent in 2021 to 15.2 percent in 2025, citing Volkswagen's annual report. It says halving wages would make the cars only about 5 percent cheaper.9
Ingo Speich, Deka Investment, a top 10 investor in Volkswagen
"Operating results were in line with low expectations. VW is in a transitional year."2
Ferdinand Dudenhoeffer, automotive analyst
Says cuts alone will not prepare Volkswagen for what lies ahead: "a war on the workforce does not forge a path for the future."6
This report
We take the point that one-off charges drove the third-quarter loss. The run asks a narrower question: whether a strike pushes the margin below zero. On the path with no new shock, a January strike does.
How to read it

Each bar shows how far one shock moves Volkswagen's margin from the path with no new shock. A longer bar means a higher margin at the end of the run.

Our reading of the coverage
The quarterly loss is mostly a writedown, and the strike threat is wider than Volkswagen

Overstated

That Volkswagen is in a mess it cannot leave soon13

Jalopnik says it will be incredibly hard for Volkswagen to pull itself out of the mess any time soon. The same article says most of the one-off items came from the Porsche writedown. In the run, the quiet spell with a mediator ends with the margin at 4.1%.

Understated

How much one-off charges weigh on the 2026 margin4

Volkswagen says its 2026 margin would be about 4 percent without the special effects, against up to 1 percent with them. No wage deal changes those charges.

The strike threat reaches past Volkswagen7

IG Metall is also planning 24-hour walkouts at Mercedes-Benz, Audi and other companies. The Volkswagen talks run alongside wage talks across the car and steel sectors.

Part 3What to doWhat to watch, and by when
08What to watch, and whenFixed October 27th, 2026 · scored in public
What to watch, and by when
Run ofOctober 27thFive testsNovember 30th to February 21stThe question settlesFebruary 28th, 2027
Nov30
By November 30th, 2026, have Volkswagen and IG Metall jointly announced a reinstated or renegotiated wage agreement?
Yes
A deal paid for with a dividend cut, or a mediator and a margin rebound.
No
A January strike, or strikes that spread to plants abroad.
Volkswagen newsroom
Dec31
By December 31st, 2026, has Germany's Federal Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs publicly confirmed that it mediated the talks?
Yes
A mediator and a margin rebound calm the dispute.
No
Lost trust feeds a wave of strikes, or a January strike.
Germany's Federal Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs
Jan8
By January 8th, 2027, has IG Metall confirmed that strikes began at Volkswagen's German plants on January 1st, 2027?
Yes
A January strike, or strikes that spread to plants abroad.
No
A mediator and a margin rebound, or a partial deal and a strike that runs out of steam.
IG Metall
Jan20
By January 20th, 2027, does Volkswagen's December 2026 delivery report show German output down from a year earlier by the level Brief 64 sets?
Yes
Unofficial strikes and a supplier collapse, or strikes that spread abroad.
No
A mediator and a margin rebound, or a partial deal and a strike that runs out of steam.
Volkswagen investor relations
Feb21
By February 21st, 2027, has Reuters or a major Mexican outlet confirmed a coordinated strike, walkout or slowdown by SITIAVW at Volkswagen's Puebla plant?
Yes
A January strike, unofficial strikes, lost trust, strikes abroad, an energy squeeze or a long fight over who runs out first.
No
Rivals waiting, a dividend-cut deal, a mediator, a partial deal and a strike that runs out of steam, or a scandal and staff poaching.
Reuters
Which test points to which outcomeA yes points hereA no points here
Dividend-cut dealMediator and reboundStrike runs out of steamSplits stall talksScandal and poachingRivals waitStrike waveWildcat strikesStrikes spread abroadJanuary strikeEnergy squeezeWho runs out firstNovember 30thA joint wage deal by November 30th?December 31stDid the labor ministry mediate by December 31st?January 8thStrikes confirmed by January 8th?January 20thA steep fall in German output in December?February 21stAction by SITIAVW, the Puebla plant union, by February 21st?
Dividend-cut dealMediator and reboundStrike runs out of steamSplits stall talksScandal and poachingRivals waitStrike waveWildcat strikesStrikes spread abroadJanuary strikeEnergy squeezeWho runs out firstNovember 30thDecember 31stJanuary 8thJanuary 20thFebruary 21st
No test points to splits inside both camps stalling the talks. The Puebla test falls in the last week before the question settles, so it warns little. The tests on November 30th and January 8th are the ones that warn early.
10How we know
How we know
20claims the run cited to a source
19of them found on the cited page
1of them the run marked unverified

This page cites 13 sources. Every number on it is traced to one of them or to the run.

What the run measures
Volkswagen's reported operating margin: its operating result as a share of sales, from its own results. The deciding line is zero.
Today's figure
We print the margin for 2025, the last full year, as Reuters reports it. We found no newsroom report that prints a reported margin for 2026 so far. The third quarter was an operating loss.
How firm this is
Each outcome is a range, and the ranges overlap. The quiet spell runs from 2.2% to 5.9%. The path with no new shock stays below zero across its whole range. The brief has one run, so there is no earlier run to compare.
The settle date
The question settles on February 28th, 2027. Volkswagen's calendar lists its annual media and investor conference for March 9th, 2027.
What we left out
We found no report on SITIAVW at the Puebla plant, or on any mediation by Germany's labor ministry. We do not print the run's past cases, because we could not check them against a report.
  • The scale was widened to hold every outcome.
  • A source contradicts something the question takes as given.
  • A real result can land past every outcome shown.
11Sources
  1. Volkswagen stung by tariffs, China battle as profit halves
  2. Volkswagen posts deepest loss since Dieselgate on Porsche writedown, China woes
  3. Volkswagen Group: Nine-month results underline urgent need for action
  4. Volkswagen AG updates its forecast for fiscal year 2026
  5. Volkswagen's workers threaten strikes unless it reinstates wage deals
  6. Angry VW union to ratchet up dispute after labour deals cut short
  7. Volkswagen seeks pay freeze, flexible hours in showdown with union
  8. 2026 collective bargaining negotiations: Volkswagen AG calls for significant relief in labor costs
  9. Volkswagen 2026/2027 Collective Bargaining Round
  10. Collective Bargaining Outcome at VW and Subsidiaries
  11. Main points of Volkswagen's restructuring plan
  12. Investors | Volkswagen Group
  13. Porsche Writedown Plunges Volkswagen Deeper Into The Financial Abyss
From our earlier work

Built on brief 64: Will VW Patch Its Wage Deal Before Strikes Hit in January?