Report 73 · State aid

The EU's subsidy rulebook expires on December 31st, and nearly every shock we tested delays its replacement

EU governments run most of their subsidies under one rulebook that lets them skip approval from Brussels. It expires on December 31st, 2026, and the new one is not adopted yet.

Run of November 7th, 2026Published November 13th, 2026Updated November 15th, 2026Settles December 31st, 2026Run checked 14 of 15 cited claims
The bottom line
The new rules arrive on time only if nothing new goes wrong. Nearly every shock we tested pushes them past December 31st and onto a stopgap.
If nothing changes
The Commission adopts the new text in time, and it applies from January 1st, 2027.
What it depends on
Whether the Commission settles the text with member states in time, and whether the Goldwind probe turns into a trade fight with China.
What to watch
Dec10

Has the Commission announced a decision on Chinese wind turbine makers under its foreign subsidies law?

Dec15

Does the Council's public register list a formal endorsement of the new rules?

Dec18

Does Parliament's procedure file show the final act signed?

Dec20

Has China's commerce ministry announced tariffs or limits on EU wind turbine parts?

Dec24

Have the new rules appeared in the EU's Official Journal?

Dec31

The current rules expire. Schemes they exempt keep their cover for an adjustment period after that.

What is happening
New EU state aid rules not adopted, due end of 2026
As of November 14th, 20261
  1. Draft publishedFebruary 25th, 2026
  2. Consultation closesApril 23rd, 2026
  3. Official Journal deadline in our testDecember 24th, 2026
  4. Current rules expireDecember 31st, 2026
The Commission decides alone, and it has not adopted the new rules

The General Block Exemption Regulation, known as GBER, lets EU governments grant certain subsidies without asking the European Commission first. In 2024, governments reported aid under 6,509 measures that used it. That was 69% of all active aid measures, against 41% in 2014.8

The current rules expire on December 31st, 2026. The Commission published a draft of new rules on February 25th, 2026, and took comments until April 23rd. Its review page still plans adoption for the end of 2026.1

The Commission adopts the new rules itself, under a Council law from 2015. That law names no vote by the European Parliament or the Council. It tells the Commission to consult the Advisory Committee on State Aid before it adopts. The committee is made up of member state representatives, and a Commission representative chairs it.9

The committee gives an opinion, by a vote if needed. The Commission must take "the utmost account" of it. The law sets no date for adoption. The committee meets at least two months after the Commission sends notice. That wait can be cut when the matter is urgent, or for a simple extension of the rules.9

The Commission says it has amended and prolonged the rulebook several times. It also said the draft would be discussed in meetings with member states. It began the revision early "to ensure a seamless transition" to the new rules.8

Expiry would not end existing schemes at once. The rulebook as adopted in 2014 keeps exempted schemes covered for six months after it expires. Regional aid schemes are the exception.10

MLex, a regulatory news service, reported on the revision on November 5th, 2026. It said the Commission was working on how the rules define companies in financial difficulty. A senior Commission official said governments want simpler rules and more legal certainty. That needs a "delicate balance", the official said.11

BDI, the Federation of German Industries, says a second draft went to member states in summer 2026. It welcomes higher thresholds from 2027 but criticizes lower aid rates for some environmental and recycling projects.3

In a separate case, the Commission opened an in-depth probe on February 3rd, 2026 into Goldwind, a Chinese wind turbine maker. It is looking at possible grants, cheap loans and tax breaks from Beijing.4

The probe can end with commitments from Goldwind, with measures imposed on it, or with no objection. The Commission says opening it does not prejudge the result.14

China's commerce ministry said the probe "seriously disrupts mutually beneficial China-EU industrial cooperation", the news agency AFP reported. It urged Brussels to "immediately correct its wrong practices".12

Goldwind asked the EU General Court to suspend a Commission information request. The court dismissed that request on July 20th, 2026.15

01Where it could land
Where the deadline lands in each outcome

New rules adopted on time

  • No new shock
  • A quiet spell
  • Capitals agree early

Old rules extended as a stopgap

  • The procedure runs out of time
  • Member states fight over aid ceilings
  • Chinese retaliation and a Parliament revolt
  • Leaks reopen the final text
  • A fight over what comes first
  • Friction inside the Commission
  • Supply bottlenecks and cheap Chinese kit
  • Side deals delay the rules

Reform stalls in a trade fight

  • The Goldwind fight spreads to trade and budget
In bold: the paths with no new shock.
Part 1The situationWhat the rulebook does and where the new one stands
02History
From a 2014 rulebook to a December deadline
  1. 2014The current rulebook enters into force.1
  2. July 2015A Council law sets out how the Commission adopts such rules.9
  3. July 2020The Commission prolongs the rulebook by its own regulation.6
  4. 2023The Commission amends the rulebook and prolongs it until the end of 2026.17
  5. July 2025The Commission opens a call for evidence on the revision.2
  6. February 3rdThe Commission opens an in-depth probe into Goldwind.4
  7. February 25thThe Commission publishes its draft and opens a consultation.2
  8. April 23rdThe consultation closes.2
  9. May 29thGoldwind asks the EU General Court to annul the Commission's information requests.5
  10. July 20thThe General Court dismisses Goldwind's request to suspend a Commission information request.15
  11. November 5thMLex reports the Commission is working on technical details of the new rules.11
  12. November 14thNo new text is adopted. The Commission's page still plans adoption for the end of 2026.1
  13. December 31stThe current rules expire.2
04Who decidesDecisions and conditions
Who can move the deadline
DecisionWho decides
Teresa Ribera
Executive Vice-President of the European Commission for the Clean, Just and Competitive Transition

She leads the Commission's competition work. She said the new rulebook "will make it easier and faster for Member States to boost the competitiveness of our industries".8

Advisory Committee on State Aid
Committee of member state representatives, chaired by the Commission

The Commission must consult it before it adopts the rules. It gives an opinion, by a vote if needed.9

DecisionThe trade fight beside it
Goldwind
Chinese wind turbine maker

Under an in-depth Commission probe since February 3rd, 2026, over possible grants, cheap loans or tax breaks from Beijing.4

China's commerce ministry
China's trade ministry

Said the Goldwind probe "seriously disrupts mutually beneficial China-EU industrial cooperation" and urged Brussels to correct its "wrong practices", AFP reported.12

Part 2The outcomesWhere each outcome leaves the deadline
05What each shock does
What each shock does to the deadline

We add each shock to the quiet path twice and see where the answer ends each time. When both tries agree, the result is firm. When they differ, it is uncertain. The quiet path is the one with no new shock.

Where the answer ends with no new shockWhere the answer ends when this shock is added
New rulesadopted ontimeOld rulesextended as astopgapReform stallsin a tradefightThe Goldwind fight spreads to trade andbudgetchanges it both timesThe procedure runs out of timechanges it both timesMember states fight over aid ceilingschanges it both timesChinese retaliation and a Parliamentrevoltchanges it both timesLeaks reopen the final textchanges it both timesA fight over what comes firstchanges it both timesFriction inside the Commissionchanges it both timesSupply bottlenecks and cheap Chinese kitchanges it both timesSide deals delay the ruleschanges it both timesCapitals agree earlyno change either time
New rules adopted ontimeOld rules extended asa stopgapReform stalls in atrade fightThe Goldwind fight spreads to trade and budgetchanges it both timesThe procedure runs out of timechanges it both timesMember states fight over aid ceilingschanges it both timesChinese retaliation and a Parliament revoltchanges it both timesLeaks reopen the final textchanges it both timesA fight over what comes firstchanges it both timesFriction inside the Commissionchanges it both timesSupply bottlenecks and cheap Chinese kitchanges it both timesSide deals delay the ruleschanges it both timesCapitals agree earlyno change either time
changes it both times
Both tries ended on a different level from the quiet path.
no change either time
Both tries ended where the quiet path ends.
06If nothing in particular happens
New rules adopted on timeNo new shock
New rules adopted on timeA quiet spell

If nothing unusual happens, the Commission adopts the new text and it applies from January 1st, 2027. The Goldwind dispute stays open on this path too.1

07The other reading
The case against our reading
European Commission
It says it began the revision before expiry "to ensure a seamless transition" to the new rules. It plans adoption for the end of 2026, before the current rules expire.8
The Council's 2015 law
It lets the Commission adopt the rules after consulting a committee of member states. It names no vote by Parliament or the Council. A revolt in Parliament has no formal hold on the text.9
BDI, the Federation of German Industries
Says a second draft went to member states in summer 2026, and still asks for changes to parts of it. The final text can still move.3
ClientEarth, an environmental law group
Welcomes the consultation but strongly opposes the draft's wider support for fossil gas and its inclusion of low-carbon fuels.16
This report
By the rule, Parliament cannot vote the text down, so that part of one shock has no formal hold. Member states still speak through the committee, and the Commission chooses when to adopt. The Official Journal question on December 24th is the one that settles it.
How to read it

Each row is one shock we tested. The track shows where the deadline lands when that shock hits.

Our reading of the coverage
The end-of-2026 date is a plan, and the Commission alone can turn it into an extension

Overstated

That the new rules will be in place by the end of 20261

The Commission's review page gives the date as a plan. In our tests the rules arrive on time only with no new shock, or when capitals agree early. Every other shock we tested pushes them past December 31st.

Understated

The Commission has extended this rulebook before6

The Commission's list of regulations shows a prolongation in 2020, by a Commission regulation. Nearly every shock we tested ends the same way, with the old rules kept on as a stopgap.

A stopgap needs no vote in Parliament or the Council9

The 2015 law lets the Commission adopt after consulting a committee of member states. For a simple extension, the law lets it shorten the wait before that committee meets.

A lapse would not cut off existing schemes at once10

The rulebook as adopted in 2014 keeps exempted schemes covered for six months after it expires, regional aid schemes aside.

Part 3What to doWhat to watch before December 31st
08What to watch, and whenFixed November 7th, 2026 · scored in public
What to watch, and by when
Run ofNovember 7thFive testsDecember 10th to December 24thThe question settlesDecember 31st, 2026
Dec10
By December 10th, 2026, has the Commission announced a decision on Chinese wind turbine makers under its foreign subsidies law? Bird & Bird, a law firm, says the Commission in principle has 18 months for the Goldwind probe.
Yes
Capitals agree early or nothing new happens. Chinese retaliation with a Parliament revolt points here too.
No
Side deals, or fights over aid ceilings and sequencing.
The European Commission's press corner
Dec15
By December 15th, 2026, does the Council's public register list a formal endorsement of the new rules?
Yes
No new shock, a quiet spell, or capitals agree early.
No
Chinese retaliation with a Parliament revolt, or fights over aid ceilings and inside the Commission.
The Council of the EU's public register
Dec18
By December 18th, 2026, does Parliament's procedure file show the final act signed?
Yes
No new shock, a quiet spell, or capitals agree early.
No
Time runs out, friction inside the Commission, a sequencing fight, or leaks.
The European Parliament's Legislative Observatory
Dec20
By December 20th, 2026, has China's commerce ministry announced tariffs or limits on EU wind turbine parts?
Yes
Chinese retaliation with a Parliament revolt, or the Goldwind fight spreading to trade and budget.
No
No new shock, a quiet spell, or capitals agree early.
China's Ministry of Commerce
Dec24
By December 24th, 2026, have the new rules appeared in the EU's Official Journal?
Yes
No new shock, a quiet spell, or capitals agree early.
No
Time runs out, leaks, a sequencing fight, internal friction, bottlenecks, a ceiling fight, or Chinese retaliation with a Parliament revolt.
EUR-Lex, the EU's law database
Which test points to which outcomeA yes points hereA no points here
No new shockQuiet spellEarly dealTime runs outCeiling fightDouble shockLeaksSequencing fightInternal frictionBottlenecksSide dealsTrade spilloverDecember 10thWind subsidy decision by December 10th?December 15thCouncil endorsement by December 15th?December 18thFinal act signed by December 18th?December 20thChinese limits on EU wind parts by December 20th?December 24thIn the Official Journal by December 24th?
No new shockQuiet spellEarly dealTime runs outCeiling fightDouble shockLeaksSequencing fightInternal frictionBottlenecksSide dealsTrade spilloverDecember 10thDecember 15thDecember 18thDecember 20thDecember 24th
The two questions on China and wind turbines are the early ones, and they warn only of the trade fight. The Council and Parliament questions rest on steps the 2015 law does not require, so a no on either warns of nothing. The Official Journal question is the main question asked a week early. No question watches the committee of member states, which is the last step the law requires.
10How we know
How we know
15claims the run cited to a source
14of them found on the cited page
1of them the run marked unverified

This page cites 17 sources. Every number on it is traced to one of them or to the run.

The question
Does the Commission adopt the new rulebook by December 31st, 2026, as published in the EU's Official Journal? The other endings are a stopgap extension, or neither.
The run
Brief 73, run on November 7th, 2026. We ran each shock twice.
Where things stand
The Commission's review page and its state aid news page, read on November 14th, 2026.
How firm this is
Every shock that delayed the rules did so both times we ran it. The fight that spreads to trade and the budget stalled the reform both times. An early deal between capitals changed nothing either time, since the quiet path already ends on time. We found no earlier run of this question to compare.
Who decides
The run wrote two of its tests as if Parliament and the Council sign off the text. The 2015 law gives the decision to the Commission, after it consults a committee of member states.
Past cases
The run found seven past cases. Four are earlier changes to this rulebook, in 2017, 2020, 2021 and 2023. The Commission's list of regulations shows each as a Commission regulation, and the 2020 one as a prolongation. The other three are different files, and no page we gathered covers them.
The sources
The Commission's pages and press releases, MLex, AFP through France 24, EUobserver, BDI, ClientEarth and law firm notes. The Council's 2015 law and the 2014 rulebook are read from the UK's legislation site.
What we left out
Dates for the second draft and for the committee's meetings. No page we gathered gives one. The amount of money that runs under the rulebook, and any figures by member state, so there is no map. Goldwind's own reply to the probe. The rulebook's current text: EUR-Lex would not store, so the six-month rule is read from the 2014 version. No page we gathered reports a financial or family interest of anyone who decides.
  • A real result can be one we did not test.
11Sources
  1. Review of the General Block Exemption Regulation
  2. EU Commission invites comments on new General Block Exemption Regulation draft
  3. European State Aid Law: New GBER needs to be fit for purpose
  4. EU opens probe into Chinese wind giant Goldwind under foreign subsidies rules
  5. Foreign Subsidies Regulation Quarterly (FSRQ) Q2 2026
  6. State aid regulations
  7. The FSR in action: the Commission investigates foreign subsidies in the renewable energy supply chain
  8. Commission invites comments on draft new State aid General Block Exemption Regulation
  9. Council Regulation (EU) 2015/1588 on the application of Articles 107 and 108 of the Treaty to certain categories of horizontal State aid
  10. Commission Regulation (EU) No 651/2014, Article 58, Transitional provisions
  11. EU state aid exemption review weighs flexibility for startups, official says
  12. China calls EU 'discriminatory' over probe into energy giant Goldwind
  13. State aid latest news
  14. Commission opens in-depth foreign subsidies investigation into Goldwind's activities in the EU wind sector
  15. The EU General Court rejects a Chinese wind-turbine manufacturer's application
  16. Revision of the General Block Exemption Regulation
  17. State aid: Commission amends General Block Exemption rules to further facilitate and speed up green and digital transition
From our earlier work

Built on brief 73: EU's state aid rulebook deadline: December 31st, with 2027 factory spending at stake