The EU is using its gatekeeper rules on AI without changing who counts as a gatekeeper

The European Commission left its designation criteria unchanged in April 2026 and on July 16th ordered Alphabet to open Android and search data to rival AI services. A late-October sell-off in Alphabet shares has revived the argument that gatekeepers are less entrenched than the law assumes.
Analysis
November 5th, 2026
Vektora
Designation criteriaUnchanged after first review
AI as a core platform serviceNot designated
Sources12 cited
As ofNov 5th, 2026
Executive Summary

The European Commission is applying its Digital Markets Act (DMA) to artificial intelligence (AI) without changing who counts as a gatekeeper. The DMA is the EU law that sets duties for the largest online platforms, which it calls gatekeepers1. After its first review, the Commission said the designation criteria will not be amended1. On July 16th, 2026 it adopted two binding decisions that tell Alphabet, Google's parent company, how to open Android features and Google Search data to rival AI services2,3.

A share-price fall is not a legal test. Alphabet shares sank more than 12% on October 29th, 2026, its worst trading day on record, after earnings missed expectations4. The Commission's review left the designation criteria unchanged1, and the sources we read do not link a gatekeeper's status to its share price. The Commission also says Google Search has held a market share of more than 90% in Europe for decades3. The sell-off matters because it feeds the argument that dominance is less durable than regulators assumed4.

For investors, the exposure sits in the cases, not the list. European authorities have brought more than 60 antitrust cases against Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta and Microsoft, and 16 are still pending, 14 of them at national level5. Apple was told it faced periodic penalty payments that could exceed 50 million euros a day6.

Antitrust cases against five US tech firms
More than 60
Cases still pending
16
First DMA fines (April 23rd, 2025)
€500 million Apple, €200 million Meta
Alphabet one-day share fall (October 29th, 2026)
More than 12%
01What the Commission decided

The Commission kept the gatekeeper test as it is and moved AI into enforcement on services it has already designated.

The first review of the DMA, published on April 28th, 2026, found the law fit for purpose and proposed no revision7,1.

The DMA requires the Commission to review it every three years under Article 53, and the first review was legally due by May 3rd, 20261. The Commission's answer was that it is not proposing to revise the DMA, and that the criteria for designating gatekeepers will not be amended1.

AI is where it did act. In November 2025 it opened three market investigations into cloud computing services, two of them on whether Amazon and Microsoft should be designated for their cloud services1. On January 27th, 2026 it opened two sets of specification proceedings, a DMA tool for spelling out how a gatekeeper must meet a duty. One covered Android features used by Google's own AI services such as Gemini. The other covered access to Google Search data, including for AI chatbot providers8.

The final decisions came on July 16th, 2026. Google must give competing AI services access to 11 Android features, in the next major Android release and by August 1st, 2027 at the latest2. On search data, Alphabet had to finalise the pricing offer by January 20273.

The Commission will assess what can be learned from these ongoing AI-related investigations to determine whether additional interventions are needed to address concerns raised in the public consultation.
European Commission, Apr 28th, 20261

On designation, the Commission says the question turns on whether an AI service is an integral part of a designated service, and so already covered, or a distinct service that might warrant designation. It will assess in particular whether certain AI services should be designated as virtual assistants1.

02How the first fines worked

The two DMA fines so far show how enforcement works in practice: dialogue first, a fine when dialogue fails, and a change in the company's terms afterwards.

On April 23rd, 2025 the Commission fined Apple €500 million for breaching its anti-steering duty, which lets app developers tell customers about cheaper offers outside the App Store9. It fined Meta €200 million because its paid-or-consent advertising model did not give users the choice of a service that uses less of their personal data9.

Fig. 1

First fines under the Digital Markets Act

Decided April 23rd, 2025, in € million

0200400600500AppleMeta

Source: European Commission, April 23rd, 20259

Apple appealed its fine. On August 18th, 2026 the Commission welcomed revised Apple terms for developers, to start in the EU in October 2026, and said it was not considering periodic penalty payments at that stage6. The company had been told it faced such payments that could exceed 50 million euros a day6.

The same press release shows the list can shrink. The Commission found that Facebook Marketplace had fewer than 10,000 business users in 2024. Meta therefore no longer met the threshold that creates a presumption of gateway status, and Marketplace is no longer designated9. Status follows a stated test applied to a named service, and the test can be met or missed.

03Where the pressure sits

Most pending cases are national, so the nearest risk for a portfolio company is a national authority, not Brussels.

Cullen International, a regulatory research firm in Brussels, counts more than 60 antitrust cases against Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta and Microsoft, with 16 still pending. Fourteen of the 16 are at national level, and the Commission's two open probes target AI-related conduct by Google and Meta5.

Fig. 2

Who runs the 16 pending antitrust cases

Cases against five US tech firms, November 2026

National authoritiesEuropean Commission

Source: Cullen International, November 4th, 20265

Those antitrust cases run under ordinary competition law, alongside the DMA, not under it5. Since the DMA became applicable in May 2023, authorities across Europe have opened more than a dozen new antitrust investigations5.

04The market's challenge

The October sell-off raises a fair question about how entrenched gatekeepers are, but a few days of trading cannot answer it.

Dirk Auer, director of competition policy at the International Center for Law & Economics (ICLE), a law and economics research group, links the sell-off to the DMA. Alphabet shares fell more than 12% on October 29th, 2026 after revenue and profit missed expectations, and its free cash flow turned negative by $9.1 billion4. Amazon said it spent $75.9 billion on capital expenditure in a single quarter against $42.4 billion in cash from operations4.

What if the dominant platforms those frameworks label “gatekeepers” aren’t nearly as entrenched as policymakers assumed?

International Center for Law & Economics4

Auer also warns that it would be unwise to read too much into a few days of trading4. We agree. A single results week shows doubt about AI spending, not a change in market structure. The Commission's own case for the search data decision rests on a market share of more than 90% for decades3. A share price can fall faster than that kind of position erodes.

05The Other Reading

Critics argue from opposite directions: that the DMA over-reaches against US firms, and that it cannot reach AI firms that are not already gatekeepers.

The Information Technology and Innovation Foundation (ITIF), a Washington technology policy group, told the US Trade Representative on October 29th, 2026 that the DMA is discriminatory and costly. It cites industry estimates of about $200 million in annual compliance costs per American gatekeeper and recommends a focused Section 301 trade investigation if talks fail10.

A second critique points the other way. Academics writing for TechPolicy.Press argue that generative AI developers that offer no other core platform service cannot be designated as gatekeepers under the DMA today, which leaves OpenAI untouched11. The Commission's reply is the route described above: apply existing duties to AI features inside designated services, and consider virtual assistants as a category1.

06Vektora Assessment

Our reading is that the designation list is stable in the near term and that AI enforcement will come through existing services.

Confidence is medium. The mechanism is documented: the Commission has said in its review that the criteria stay, and its two Alphabet decisions show AI being handled through duties on a service already designated1,2,3. The horizon is less certain, because the Commission has not said when it will decide whether any AI service warrants its own designation1.

The strongest alternative reading is that investor doubt about AI spending will weaken the political case for strict rules before the next review. We found no source showing that effect yet, so we do not rely on it.

What would change our view: a Commission decision to designate an AI service as a core platform service, or a proposal to amend the designation criteria. A court ruling that narrows the specification decisions would also count, since they remain subject to judicial review12.

07Client Implications

Readers should track named national cases and AI-related specification steps rather than the designation list.

  • Private equity and venture investors: ask portfolio companies that depend on Apple, Google or Meta distribution which duties already changed their terms, such as Apple's revised developer terms from October 20266.
  • Corporates: check cloud and AI supply contracts for the interoperability and data access questions the Commission lists as AI themes1.
  • Law firms: follow the Alphabet implementation dates and the cloud market investigations, since both set precedent for AI-related duties2,1.
08Sources
  1. DMA Review Q&A. European Commission, April 28th, 2026
  2. Alphabet specification proceedings: Interoperability for AI services. European Commission, July 16th, 2026
  3. Alphabet specification proceedings: Sharing of Google Search data. European Commission, July 16th, 2026
  4. AI Is Picking the Locks on Europe's Gatekeeper Rules. International Center for Law & Economics, November 2nd, 2026
  5. More than 60 cases and counting: a snapshot of European antitrust enforcement against big tech. Cullen International, November 4th, 2026
  6. EU 'welcomes' Apple steps to comply with digital rules. Courthouse News Service (AFP), August 18th, 2026
  7. The European Commission's First Review of the Digital Markets Act: AI and Cloud in the Spotlight. Ashurst Perkins Coie via JD Supra, May 21st, 2026
  8. Commission opens proceedings to assist Google in complying with interoperability and online search data sharing obligations under the Digital Markets Act. European Commission, January 27th, 2026
  9. Commission finds Apple and Meta in breach of the Digital Markets Act. European Commission, April 23rd, 2025
  10. Comments to USTR on Foreign Trade Barriers for the 2027 National Trade Estimate Report. Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, October 29th, 2026
  11. Will the EU Designate AI Under the Digital Markets Act? TechPolicy.Press
  12. Commission provides guidance to Google for AI interoperability on Android and sharing of Google Search data under the Digital Markets Act. Public Affairs Bruxelles, July 16th, 2026