Article 58 · Antitrust

Kroger's $1.65 billion Giant Eagle deal would put it close to half of Columbus groceries, an advocacy group says

Kroger, a Cincinnati supermarket company, wants to buy Giant Eagle, a family-owned chain near Pittsburgh. An antitrust advocacy group says regulators should block it. No agency has acted.

Nov 9th, 2026 · 4 min read · By Vektora

What is being bought

Kroger is a supermarket company based in Cincinnati. It runs roughly 2,700 stores across the United States. On July 1st, 2026 it agreed to buy Giant Eagle, a family-owned grocery and pharmacy chain based near Pittsburgh.

The price is $1.65 billion. That is $1.25 billion in cash plus about $400 million in debts and other liabilities that Kroger would take on. Giant Eagle has 197 supermarkets and 11 standalone pharmacies in northern Ohio, western Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Maryland and Indiana. Its yearly sales are about $9 billion.

Both companies expect the deal to close in 2027, after regulators clear it. They expect to sell a limited number of Giant Eagle stores to get that clearance. As of July, Kroger had not said how many.

The Federal Trade Commission, the US agency that reviews mergers, is likely to handle the review. A Giant Eagle spokesperson told CBS Pittsburgh the company cannot comment because of the ongoing FTC review.

Why Columbus is the flashpoint

On October 28th, 2026 the American Economic Liberties Project published a brief called "Big Grocery is Watching You." The group is a nonprofit in Washington that argues for tougher antitrust enforcement. It asks the FTC and Ohio's attorney general to block the deal.

The group says Kroger already holds 43% of the grocery market in the Columbus area. It says the deal would take that share close to 50%. It also says that in three places a Giant Eagle store sits directly across the street from a Kroger.

Another figure points the other way. Advan Research, a location-data firm, found that only about 7% of Giant Eagle's supermarkets are within 5 miles of a Kroger store. The two numbers measure different things. The 7% covers Giant Eagle's whole chain. The 43% is Kroger's share in one metro area.

Giant Eagle trailed only Walmart in Northeast Ohio grocery market share as recently as 2024, according to Axios Cleveland.

The shopper data argument

The advocacy group's strongest claim is about data, not store counts. It says the deal hands Kroger Giant Eagle's loyalty-card records, the purchase histories tied to each shopper's rewards card.

Kroger's own announcement points the same way. Its chief executive, Greg Foran, said Giant Eagle's loyalty program is part of the foundation for growth. He said Kroger would combine it with Kroger's "data and personalization capabilities."

The group cites an estimate that Kroger's precision marketing division earned $527 million in profit in 2024. That division turns shopper data into marketing products for other companies. The estimate comes from Consumer Reports, which attributes it to Guggenheim Securities, an investment bank. Kroger does not publish division profits.

The group also points to Kroger's privacy policy. It discloses facial recognition at select stores and cameras that can capture license plates. Kroger has denied using facial recognition for pricing. Kroger did not respond to Axios about the report.

What lawyers and senators have said

In July, antitrust lawyers told Grocery Dive that the Giant Eagle deal should be easier to clear than Kroger's failed Albertsons merger. The FTC sued to block that earlier deal in February 2024. Barry Barnett, an antitrust lawyer at the firm Susman Godfrey, said he expected the agency to be "much more friendly towards the merger."

Spencer Waller, an antitrust law professor at Loyola University Chicago, said the FTC is now interested in settlements. He said a strong plan to sell stores where the chains overlap gives the companies a good chance. He still expects a second request, a demand for more information that the FTC makes only in rare cases.

Waller also said state attorneys general could oppose the deal or ask for a stronger plan to sell stores. In October, Massachusetts Senator Elizabeth Warren wrote to the FTC and the Justice Department urging them to scrutinize the deal. She said the two chains' territories overlap considerably.

What to watch

As of November 4th, 2026, no agency, state or court has acted on the advocacy group's report. It is a proposal from one side. Figure 1 shows how the deal has moved so far.

The first signal is whether Kroger or Giant Eagle discloses a second request, in a press release or a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Kroger's quarterly filings would carry it. The second is whether either names a buyer for the stores to be sold, or says how many.

Fig. 1

How the deal has moved

  1. February 2024The FTC and eight states sue to block Kroger's merger with Albertsons.
  2. July 1st, 2026Kroger announces it will buy Giant Eagle for $1.65 billion.
  3. July 14th, 2026Antitrust lawyers tell Grocery Dive the deal should be easier to clear.
  4. October 28th, 2026The American Economic Liberties Project urges regulators to block it.
All articlesNext Tigers are up more than 70 percent, yet WWF's index finds the average wildlife population down 73 percent since 1970